If A, then B…or not.

wood 2Bob says my head is a scary place to visit.  Truth be told, he does occasionally admit that that’s one of the reasons he married me 35+ years ago.  To this day, he says that I’m “irregular”.  In the common sense, it’s both a blessing…and a curse.

I tried teaching myself logic from an authentically academic book.  Not the term “logic” that is generously used in everyday usage, although that idea harkens back to the true definition, I suppose.  One of the few things I got out of this autodidactic exercise, (besides that fact that I probably wasn’t going to learn this without a qualified teacher…), is that false premises lead to faulty conclusions.  In other words, my conclusion, or interpretation of the data, may seem to make sense, until I find out that the data was incomplete, or worse, downright wrong.

A clear case of this is the story of the Old Testament prophet, Jeremiah, confronting a bunch of women hell-bent (literally) on idolatry.  The Hebrew nation was now under severe attack from the Babylonians, something God had been warning them about for a L-O-N-G time, trying to ward off the ensuing destruction.  (And one lone male facing down a bevy of angry females in various states of hormonal upheaval is not to be under-appreciated…)  I could summarize, but it reads well as is.  We open the scene with the women~~

 “For in those days we had plenty to eat, and we were well off and had no troubles! But ever since we quit burning incense to the Queen of Heaven and stopped worshiping her with liquid offerings, we have been in great trouble and have been dying from war and famine.”

“Besides,” the women added, “do you suppose that we were burning incense and pouring out liquid offerings to the Queen of Heaven, and making cakes marked with her image, without our husbands knowing it and helping us? Of course not!”

(That’s right, bring the men in on it…)

“Then Jeremiah said to all of them, men and women alike, who had given him that answer,… ‘It was because the LORD could no longer bear all the disgusting things you were doing that he made your land an object of cursing— a desolate ruin without inhabitants— as it is today.  All these terrible things happened to you because you have burned incense to idols and sinned.’”

The outcome resolved quite badly since their thinking about the situation was woefully inadequate:

To begin with, these gals totally misunderstood authentic relationship with God.  To their credit, they knew they needed to take care of their families, but never is it justifiable to use God as a cosmic cash-cow.  I can’t serve Him with the caveat that He’ll take care of all my earthly desires, or sometimes even (gulp!) my temporal needs in the way that I expect. That’s not the kind of relationship He died on the cross for!  There’s the wholehearted, all-embracing part, and the come-what-may obedience that is borne from that trusting relationship. 

Secondly, they missed the part about heavenly timing.  God’s blessing “overtakes” us, or catches up to us as we consistently and relentless walk in this sold-out intimacy with Him. 

Their original premises were wrong.  Therefore, (that’s a word they actually use in logic; there’s even a symbol for it!), therefore, the women—yes, and the men—got their conclusion completely wrong.  Because following the God of the Universe is always the best option…

From: sites.millersville.edu, but it’s all Greek to me….

…it’s just logical.



Jeremiah 44:17-23  Tyndale House Publishers Inc (2008-06-01). The One Year Bible NLT (One Year Bible: Nlt Book 2) (Kindle Locations 35356-35364). Tyndale House Publishers. Kindle Edition.

Author: dawnlizjones

Tends toward TMI, so here's the short list: guitar and banjo (both of which have been much neglected as of late), bicycling (ibid), dogs, very black tea, and contemplating and commenting on deep philosophical thoughts about which I have had no academic or professional training. Oh, also reading, writing, but I shy away from arithmetic.

9 thoughts on “If A, then B…or not.”

  1. I like formal logic, even though I can never remember which is induction and which is deduction. Your use of logic to describe Jeremiah’s conversation with the idolatrous women is very well done. The Roman Empire followed the same logic for three hundred years. They were always ready to add another god, but they resisted the teaching of Christians that only one God is real. Therefore, from time to time, they required every Christian to sacrifice to other gods or to face persecution. As Rome lost battles to the incoming tribes, the Christians and their neglect of the many gods was blamed and persecution increased. In the end, though, Christ prevailed. J.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I wish I had had the opportunity to study formal logic when I was younger. I tried some self-study, which was great, but could only go so far. I hope to audit some classes after retirement. But how often our conclusions, thought logically reached, are still erroneous, because our premises are wrong!


  2. Ha ha… That’s funny Dawn. Gary says the same thing about me… of course, it could have to do with the ‘character monologes’ and costumes, or maybe that after 43 years of marriage I still wear him out. Whatever it is, the fact that you are irregular (as Bob puts it) is a definite plus in my book…and probably why I enjoy your blog so much! So here’s to irregular and another great post!! 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: